Senate Passes a Band-Aid, When America Is Asking for Real Comprehensive Reform

Immigrant Advocates Express Outrage Over “More of the Same” Border Spending Bill

by Reform Immigration FOR America

Washington D.C. – Last week, Senate Democrats introduced and passed a last-minute $600 million border enforcement bill. This enforcement-only package includes funding for over 1,500 Border Patrol and Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents and Customs and Border Protection officers at the southern border, as well as funding for unmanned aerial drones and other enforcement activities. This action comes less than just 2 months after an earlier decision by the Senate not to include such spending in the Fiscal Year 2010 Emergency Supplemental bill they sent to the House. This Senate-passed bill could be taken up by the House of Representatives as early as tomorrow.  The following is a statement from Ali Noorani, Executive Director of the National Immigration Forum and Chair of the Reform Immigration FOR America Campaign.

“Last week, by succumbing to crass political considerations, rather than sound policy-making, Senate Democrats succeeded in clumsily orchestrating an outrageous betrayal of immigrant, faith, law enforcement, border communities and Latino communities by rushing yet another symbolic border enforcement bill through the Senate that throws more enforcement dollars at an already broken immigration system.  To add insult to injury, the Democrats did so without any indication that Senate Republicans were prepared to renew negotiations on comprehensive immigration reform legislation. This bill is a massive tax-payer funded band-aid to hold together an immigration system that needs an overhaul.

As Homeland Security Secretary has stated, there are now more resources at the southern border than ever, and security experts from a wide range of political perspectives agree that the border is as secure as it can be without comprehensive immigration reform.  The facts are also clear: crime rates are down at the southern border, spillover violence from Mexico has not manifested, and illegal immigration is at its lowest point in a decade.  We need real solutions that can help this nation move forward, strengthen its economy, control its borders and live up to its values as a nation of laws and immigrants.

It’s time for our policy makers to stop playing politics.  It’s time for Senators and Representatives to roll their sleeves up and get to work on lasting solutions for the good of this nation. Poll after poll demonstrate that politicians who lean into the issue of immigration reform are on strong footing with the majority of Americans, because they are committed to security and real solutions to a system that needs to be fixed.   Are House and Senate leaders still committed to acting on comprehensive immigration reform legislation? It’s time for them to prove it.”

For additional resources on border security, please visit:
2010 National Guard Deployments to the Southwest Border
This fact sheet contains basic information on the deployment of the National Guard on the southwest border in the summer of 2010, including number, location, and the role the Guard will play.

Operation Streamline and its Effects on the Courts and Law Enforcement on the Border
Operation Streamline is a government initiative to criminally prosecute persons crossing the border illegally. This backgrounder discusses the effect of the program on law enforcement and court resources on the border, which have been diverted away from the prosecution of more serious crimes.

The Border Security Buildup: True Border Security Requires Reforming Our Broken Immigration Laws
This backgrounder describes the increases in enforcement resources that have been placed on the southwest border in recent years, and questions the assumption that the borders are “out of control.”

National Immigration Forum’s blog:
Would Answering Demands for More Enforcement Allow Us to Move on Immigration Reform?
Border Security Mania:


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s