The Schumer Proposal: Members Weigh-in on the Good, Bad, Ugly for Immigrants

Over the course of one week in the month of May, more than 130 colonia leaders and LUPE members from around the Valley convened to decide LUPE’s stance on immigration legislation proposed by New York Senator Charles E. Schumer.

The proposed legislation, offered as a compromise between conservative proponents of border security and law enforcement and advocates of a path to citizenship, would increase border militarization while at the same time include both the DREAM and AgJOBS acts. It has been referred to as a “border-first” bill, meaning a crackdown on illegal immigration and heightened border militarization would be given first priority.

Schumer Process 01 present

Colonia leaders convened in four meetings in different Valley cities to discuss the merits and faults of the proposed legislation. LUPE organizers and leaders took turns explaining parts of the proposal, breaking down key elements within the bill and opening it up for discussion after each part.

Schumer Process 02 group discuss

LUPE members applauded the inclusion of the DREAM Act and AgJOBS bills, but raised concern over increased immigration enforcement. While some favored increased border security to protect against cartel violence spilling over the border, many did not like the added Border Patrol presence the bill would bring to their communities.

Many were tired of waiting years for a path towards legalization. One commenter, discouraged, said, “We are going to get more immigration enforcement anyway, so if we don’t take this we lose AgJOBS and the DREAM Act.”

Schumer Process 05 vote

After small group discussion, the proposal was brought to a vote. Of the 132 members voting, 121 vote to support the proposal.

Leaders then asked members to come up with ways that we can attempt to minimize the damage done by the bill and maximize its benefits. Members proposed calling Senators, organizing marches, and raising awareness in the community about the proposal.

Schumer Process 06 vote

To close, the group reflected on the importance of having these sessions. Members said that participating in the meeting allowed them to create an informed community by helping them understand what immigration reform really looks like and preparing them to go out and talk about the proposal. It also allowed the members to find unity around a vision for comprehensive immigration reform.

Organizers then encouraged colonia leaders to take up this push to improve the Schumer proposal. “This is something that has to be done by everyone,” said one organizer. “It can’t be the organizers alone.”


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s